On this page
- Choose by the edge you spend time on
- Separate making an edge from maintaining it
- Check whether shears suit your hands and the border
- Choose the right sort of trimmer for your layout
- Factor in spools, battery cost and safe use
- Decide how to deal with a mix of borders and obstacles
- Check line feed and maintenance before you switch
- Make your decision after one practice round
Choose by the edge you spend time on
Long-handled edging shears are a good starting point for short, defined borders and for patches close to plants you want to keep. A cordless grass trimmer is worth considering if you regularly clear a long fence line or the mower leaves grass around several obstacles. Walk one loop of the lawn and notice how much is a clean edge and how much is grass you need to cut around something.
A garden with one short flowerbed and a long run beside a wall may benefit from using more than one tool. Shears can handle the flowerbed, while a trimmer suited to the long run saves time elsewhere. If it’s just one small patch, try a tool you already own before adding something that needs a charger, line and space in the shed.
Separate making an edge from maintaining it
A clear vertical boundary is much easier to follow than an overgrown lip where turf has crept into a border. If you need to create or redefine the line, the RHS suggests a half-moon edging tool. Decide where the lawn should end and follow the RHS guidance to make the edge. Edging shears are useful for the extra growth hanging over that line once the edge is in place.
The grass along a fence or round a tree may need a different approach. You’re shortening grass the mower can’t reach, rather than recreating a line in the soil. A trimmer can help with longer runs. Close to tender stems and tree bark, go carefully and use a suitable hand tool where you need more control. Set up the job around the plants and surfaces you want to keep.
| What you’re dealing with | Try first | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Short, defined flowerbed edge | Long-handled edging shears | Control close to plants |
| Turf has crept into the border | Half-moon edging tool | Redefines the line for future cuts |
| Long fence line or lots of obstacles | Manageable cordless trimmer | Covers repeated runs of missed grass |
| Straight hard boundary | Trimmer with suitable edging mode | Check sight line and head control |
Check whether shears suit your hands and the border
Look for long-handled lawn edging shears that let you work upright and hold the blades where you need them. Check handle length, grip and how far the handles open. A small border might take a few minutes to finish, while a long run makes the repeated movement add up. If you have limited grip or a tricky position to reach, try the action before deciding.
Shears can be handy around a short curved bed and for working alongside a boundary you don’t want a spinning line to touch. They need little storage and no battery. Look at how the maker recommends sharpening, adjusting or replacing parts and whether you can do that comfortably. If you’ve been using hand shears and find the repeated snipping is the part that puts you off all season, that’s a good reason to compare a powered tool.
Choose the right sort of trimmer for your layout
For following a paved edge, check whether the head or handle changes to an edging position and whether it’s comfortable to hold there. A small guide or wheel can be useful on an even boundary if the model includes one and the manual shows that use. For grass in a tight corner, check the size of the head and guard and whether you can see the working area clearly.
For a long, low fence or border, compare ready-to-use weight, reach and how the handle adjusts. The more powerful machine may be a poor fit if it’s awkward for the small areas you trim most often. Check the manufacturer’s advice around hard surfaces and whether the cutting system uses line or another approved head. A dedicated edging tool could also be worth comparing if the job is mainly a straight, hard boundary and you need to define it repeatedly.
Factor in spools, battery cost and safe use
A cordless trimmer listing may show the tool alone. Check the working weight with the compatible pack fitted, and add the battery and charger if you need them. If the job is several short passes, ease of handling may matter more than a larger pack. Our battery compatibility guide explains what to check before sharing a battery with another garden tool.
Look up the correct replacement spool. Some heads let you refill line to the maker’s specification, while others are easier to maintain with the listed pre-wound spool. The spare-parts guide explains how to match line and spool codes. Read the manual for the guard, protective equipment and safe distance from people or pets, and clear stones and debris before starting. Keep electrical equipment away from wet outdoor conditions.
Decide how to deal with a mix of borders and obstacles
For a straight run of paving with a short length of grass overhanging, a pair of shears can give a tidy finish with little setup. A long boundary divided by benches, fence posts and a washing line is a better reason to compare trimmers. Walk around those obstacles with the tool switched off in your mind and think through where you can stand, what you can see and where the line would be close to something you want to protect.
If a border has lost its shape, start by restoring the lawn edge. A machine for trimming grass may do little to make that job quicker. If the grass itself is soggy, wait before mowing or trimming with electrical equipment. Use our guide to mowing after rain to judge the lawn and schedule the two jobs together.
Check line feed and maintenance before you switch
A trimmer that’s quick to set up can still be frustrating if feeding or replacing line is awkward. Check whether the head feeds line automatically, by a bump action or by another method set out in its manual. Look at how you’d reach the spool and whether a pre-wound replacement suits you better than refilling. For shears, how the blades clean and whether you can get to the pivot for routine care are similar day-to-day checks. Pick the routine you’ll be happy to repeat after the grass has grown back.
Make your decision after one practice round
Pick a small area and decide where you’d use shears, where you’d use a trimmer and where the boundary needs redefining. Check whether those few minutes are the whole job or one of several sections. If shears cover most of your work comfortably, try them through a full cut before you buy more kit. If you regularly postpone the long run or find the repeated movement tiring, use our grass-trimmer buying checklist to shortlist a manageable cordless model.
Compare whichever tool you pick with how the mower leaves the edges. If you’re buying a mower as well, our small-garden guide can help you choose the main tool around access and turning. That leaves you free to pick the simplest way to finish the grass it misses.